• Beyond Banks
  • Posts
  • Basel III Drives Worst Lending Confidence Drop Since 2020

Basel III Drives Worst Lending Confidence Drop Since 2020

SFNet Q1 2025 ABL Index Released

Bank confidence plummeted 14.1 points to 49.1 in Q1 2025, while non-banks dropped 12.5 points to 52.5. This is the worst decline since Q1 2020. When lenders are this pessimistic despite continued demand, you know the fundamentals are shifting.

Non-bank criticized loans and non-accruals are climbing. For banks, non-accruals rose but remained within historical ranges, while criticized loans dropped 180 basis points. The divergence between bank and non-bank performance is telling us something important about risk migration.

Basel III Impact

Basel III endgame takes effect July 2025 with a three-year phase-in through June 2028. The impact is straightforward: banks with over $100 billion in assets face a 16% increase in Core Equity Tier 1 capital requirements (Atlantic Council, May 2025).

What This Actually Means for ABL: Banks are shifting to partnership models rather than direct competition. They're becoming originators and syndicators while non-banks handle the balance sheet risk. This isn't temporary regulatory arbitrage, it's a permanent structural shift.

The Real Opportunity: Non-bank lenders who can move fast and structure creative deals have a clear runway. Banks face operational risk capital requirements based on fee income, making traditional ABL less attractive for them (Marex, March 2024).

Trade Policy Reality Check

Q1 2025 saw borrowers drawing down existing lines ahead of anticipated tariffs. But here's the problem: this artificial demand is masking underlying weakness. Total commitments for banks fell 1.7% and for non-banks fell 2.2%. New outstandings for non-banks plunged 57.4% while banks rose 9.8% (SFNet Q1 2025 Index).

The Disconnect: Companies are borrowing defensively while lenders are pulling back on new commitments. This creates a utilization squeeze that typically precedes margin compression and credit deterioration.

Private Credit: The Numbers Make Sense

The private credit market reached $3 trillion in assets under management in 2024, deploying $333.4 billion in fresh capital (Alternative Investment Management Association, November 2024). The larger opportunity estimates of $40 trillion represent the total addressable market as banks shed assets under regulatory pressure (Morningstar, December 2024).

Asset-Based Finance Growth: Corporate lending still dominates at 60% of private credit AUM, but asset-backed, real estate, and infrastructure debt now account for 40% of the market. This shift directly competes with traditional ABL (AIMA/EY Research, 2024).

What Smart Lenders Are Actually Doing

Receivables Financing Dominance: This segment captured 45% of the ABL market in 2023 because it provides the fastest path to liquidity without traditional loan requirements (Market.us, December 2024).

Technology Integration: Winners are implementing automated borrowing base calculations, AI-driven risk assessment, and real-time asset monitoring. But ROI varies significantly by implementation, and many lenders are overpaying for technology that doesn't move the needle on deal flow or margins.

What's Actually Happening:

  • Banks are retreating from direct ABL competition while maintaining origination relationships

  • Non-bank lenders have a clear structural advantage but face increased competition for quality deals

  • Borrowers are drawing down existing facilities while new commitment growth slows

  • Private credit firms are moving aggressively into asset-backed finance traditionally dominated by ABL lenders

What This Means for Lenders:

  • Focus on partnership opportunities with banks looking to syndicate risk

  • Invest in technology that actually improves underwriting speed and accuracy, not just data collection

  • Prepare for margin compression as competition intensifies for quality middle-market borrowers

  • Consider specialization in sectors where you have genuine expertise rather than chasing every deal

The Real Risk: This isn't about market growth rates or regulatory compliance. It's about positioning for a market where the competitive dynamics have permanently shifted. Lenders who adapt to the new partnership economy will thrive. Those who keep fighting the last war will get squeezed out by both banks and private credit firms operating with different cost structures and regulatory constraints.

The Inventory Financing Opportunity

While lenders wring their hands about "artificial demand" from tariff-driven borrowing, smart ABL shops are positioning themselves for the real opportunity: permanent inventory expansion. Companies aren't just drawing down lines defensively, they're fundamentally restructuring their supply chains.

The Real Numbers: Manufacturing companies are building 3-6 months of buffer inventory instead of just-in-time models. Retailers are expanding warehouse capacity by 20-40% to avoid stockouts. Distributors are regionalizing inventory to reduce transportation risks. This isn't temporary, it's the new operating model.

The ABL Angle: These companies need working capital facilities sized for permanently higher inventory levels. The opportunity is structuring advances against these elevated inventory positions with monitoring systems designed for the new normal.

Focus on:

  • Import-dependent manufacturers building component buffers

  • Consumer goods companies stockpiling finished products

  • Industrial distributors expanding regional inventory hubs

Pricing Power: When borrowers need larger facilities to support strategic inventory builds, they'll pay for certainty and speed. This is relationship lending, not commodity financing.

Technology That Actually Creates Competitive Advantage

Every lender talks about AI and automation, but the real differentiation is in predictive portfolio monitoring. While competitors focus on loan origination technology, winners are investing in systems that prevent losses.

Early Warning Systems: Deploy technology that identifies problems 60-90 days before they become defaults:

  • Accounts receivable aging patterns that predict collection issues

  • Inventory turnover anomalies that signal operational problems

  • Cash flow models that flag covenant breaches before they happen

  • Supplier payment delays that indicate working capital stress

The ROI Reality: A system that prevents one $2 million loss pays for itself. A system that lets you restructure proactively instead of reactively managing workouts creates lasting competitive advantage.

Implementation Focus: Don't automate everything, automate what matters. Predictive monitoring beats faster borrowing base calculations every time.

The Distressed Goldmine: When Sentiment Collapses, Opportunities Multiply

Bank confidence at 49.1 and rising criticized loans aren't problems, they're profit opportunities for experienced ABL lenders who understand how to capitalize on market pessimism.

Portfolio Acquisition Plays:

  • Banks cleaning up balance sheets ahead of regulatory examinations are selling ABL portfolios at significant discounts

  • Non-bank lenders who overextended during the growth years are looking for exit strategies

  • Distressed borrowers with solid asset bases need refinancing out of bank relationships before workout scenarios develop

The Acquisition Financing Opportunity: When strong companies acquire distressed competitors, they need ABL facilities to finance the acquisition and working capital to integrate operations. These deals combine growth financing with asset-based security.

Workout Avoidance Premium: Companies in early-stage financial stress will pay premium pricing to avoid formal workout processes. The key is identifying these situations early through your monitoring systems and offering refinancing solutions before problems become public.

Competitive Positioning: While banks retreat due to regulatory constraints and private credit shops struggle with asset-based underwriting complexity, experienced ABL lenders can cherry-pick the best opportunities with improved pricing and tighter structures.

The Private Credit Arbitrage

Private credit firms moving into asset-backed finance creates arbitrage opportunities for lenders who actually understand collateral-based underwriting.

Where They're Making Mistakes:

  • Underpricing complex inventory and receivables structures

  • Over-relying on cash flow models instead of asset coverage

  • Missing seasonal working capital requirements

  • Inadequate monitoring systems for asset-based facilities

Your Competitive Edge: When private credit shops bid on deals outside their expertise, you can either win the business with superior structuring or let them learn expensive lessons while you focus on opportunities they can't handle.

Partnership Opportunities: Some private credit firms recognize their limitations and seek ABL expertise through partnership structures. This creates fee income opportunities without balance sheet risk.

Our Opinion

While everyone's panicking about confidence dropping and deal quality deteriorating, smart lenders will see the biggest opportunity in alternative lending since 2008.

Banks with $100+ billion in assets face a 16% capital requirement increase. They're not just reducing ABL exposure, they're actively looking for non-bank partners to originate deals they can't hold. This isn't temporary regulatory gaming, it's permanent structural change.

Private credit shops are chasing $50+ million deals while regional banks retreat from the $5-25 million sweet spot. That leaves a massive gap for lenders who can move fast and price appropriately.

That sentiment collapse to 49.1 confidence? Perfect. When banks are pessimistic, spreads widen and terms improve. The 57.4% drop in new non-bank outstandings just means less competition for quality borrowers.

Smart money isn't running from this market, it's building partnerships with banks who need origination help and investing in automated monitoring systems to catch problems early.

Every lender complaining about margin compression is missing the point. Banks are literally being forced to send alternative lenders their deal flow while keeping the economics. You either capitalize on this regulatory gift or watch someone else do it.

The question isn't whether to lend in this environment. It's whether you're positioned to take advantage when your competition is cowering.

1-Minute Video: What Services Does Cobalt Intelligence offer?

What Makes Cobalt Intelligence Different?

1. Real-time data vs. cached competitors: Minutes-fresh information vs. weeks-old data
2. Direct state database integration: No middleman data degradation
3. REST API implementation: Less than one week deployment
4. Comprehensive Verification Ecosystem
- Secretary of State verification (business entity status)
- TIN Verification (tax ID validation)
- UCC Filing data (lien discovery)
- Contractor License verification (regulatory compliance)

Subscribe to our Beyond Banks Podcast Channels

Headlines You Don’t Want to Miss

Beaufort Capital has launched a dedicated real estate bridging lender, Beaufort Bridging, to support borrowers across England, Scotland, and Wales with loans ranging from £1 million to over £75 million, secured against a wide range of asset classes including residential, semi-commercial, commercial, and undeveloped land. The new lender aims to deploy more than £500 million in the first three years, providing certainty, fast decisions, and bespoke service to established developers and borrowers.

Citi Commercial Bank has upgraded its lending processes for mid-sized corporates by launching a digitally-native credit experience through the CitiDirect Commercial Banking platform, streamlining applications, enabling electronic signatures, and speeding up approvals. These enhancements, now available in the U.S., Canada, India, Singapore, Hong Kong, and Brazil, are designed to accelerate turnaround times, simplify documentation, and improve overall client experience as part of Citi’s broader digitalization strategy.

Brokers like Christopher Pepe of LoanGeek.com focus on difficult cases (“deals with hair on them”), such as large second mortgages on speculative properties or loans on assets with multiple defaults and liens. These files require more work but present significant opportunities, as fewer competitors are willing to handle them.

Get Free Access to our Cobalt Modern Underwriter GPT

Get Free Access to our Alternative Funding Expert GPT

Get Free Access to our AI Credit Risk Tool

Create an account to Get Free Access to our Secretary of State AI Tool

Subscribe on our YouTube Channel here

See us on LinkedIn