CFPB's Payday Lending Rule Starts Mar 30, 2025

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's (CFPB) payday lending rule is set to take effect on March 30, 2025, following a significant Supreme Court decision that upheld the agency's funding mechanism

Key Rule Provisions

• Lenders are restricted from making more than two unsuccessful attempts to withdraw from a borrower's account unless they have explicit authorization.

• Mandates that lenders issue prior notifications regarding payment attempts.

• Aims to protect consumers from repeated failed payment withdrawals that incur excessive fees

Main Changes in the CFPB's Payday Lending Rule

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's (CFPB) payday lending rule has undergone notable changes since its inception in 2017. The primary modifications include:

1. Rescission of the Ability-to-Repay Requirement:

• Original Provision (2017): Lenders were mandated to assess a borrower's ability to repay a loan before issuance, ensuring that consumers could afford the loan without re-borrowing or defaulting.

• Change (2020): The CFPB rescinded this requirement, eliminating the obligation for lenders to conduct such assessments.

2. Retention of Payment Provisions:

• Prohibition on Multiple Withdrawal Attempts: Lenders are restricted from making further withdrawal attempts from a borrower's account after two consecutive failed attempts due to insufficient funds, unless the borrower provides new authorization.

• Advance Notice Requirement: Lenders must give consumers prior notice before attempting to withdraw a payment for the first time and before subsequent attempts that involve different dates, amounts, or payment channels.

3. Implementation Timeline:

• Initial Effective Date: The rule was originally set to take effect in 2019.

• Revised Effective Date: Due to legal challenges and subsequent delays, the payment provisions are now scheduled to become effective on March 30, 2025.

Impact of CFPB Payday Lending Rule on Alternative Business Lenders

1. Operational Costs and System Upgrades:

Compliance with the CFPB's payment provisions will necessitate significant adjustments to your existing systems. These include implementing mechanisms to monitor consecutive failed payment attempts and ensuring the capability to obtain new consumer authorizations when required.

The costs associated with these upgrades can vary widely based on factors such as the complexity of your current infrastructure and the need for staff training. While exact figures are difficult to pinpoint without a detailed assessment, industry estimates suggest that small to mid-sized lenders might face compliance costs ranging from tens to hundreds of thousands of dollars. See key point # 5. Technological Infrastructure Needs

2. Competitive Implications:

The financial burden of compliance disproportionately affects smaller lenders, potentially leading to market consolidation. Larger institutions often have more resources to absorb these costs, whereas smaller players may struggle, potentially resulting in reduced competition and fewer options for consumers.

3. Future Business Model Adaptations:

To maintain profitability under the new regulations, lenders might consider:

• Product Diversification: Offering longer-term installment loans that may not fall under the same regulatory constraints.

• Interest Rate Adjustments: Reevaluating pricing strategies to offset increased compliance expenses.

• Enhanced Underwriting Practices: Improving credit assessment processes to reduce default rates and associated costs.

4. Interaction with State-Level Regulations:

It's crucial to recognize that state regulations can impose additional requirements or restrictions beyond federal rules. Some states have their own payday lending laws, which may include interest rate caps, licensing requirements, or outright bans. Navigating this patchwork of regulations requires a comprehensive compliance strategy tailored to each jurisdiction in which you operate.

5. Technological Infrastructure Needs:

Achieving compliance will likely require:

• Automated Payment Monitoring Systems: To track payment attempts and identify consecutive failures.

• Customer Notification Mechanisms: Ensuring timely and accurate communication with borrowers regarding payment attempts and obtaining necessary authorizations.

• Managing Consumer Authorizations: Efficiently obtaining and storing new authorizations from consumers after failed payment attempts.

• Data Security Enhancements: Protecting sensitive consumer information in compliance with both federal and state regulations.

Vendors specialize in providing compliance-focused loan management systems (LMS)

• Vergent LMS: Offers a comprehensive platform designed to navigate complex regulatory requirements, with features like automated loan origination and audit control.

• Bryt Software: Provides tools for transparent reporting, including batched 1098 and 1099 reports, and efficient notice management to streamline communication processes.

• CompassWay: Delivers a payday loan management software that automates application processing, risk assessment, and payment scheduling to enhance workflow efficiency.

When selecting a vendor, consider factors such as integration capabilities with your existing systems, scalability, user interface, customer support, and, importantly, the ability to adapt to both federal and state regulatory changes.

6. Impact on Loan Volumes and Revenue Projections:

The implementation of the CFPB's payment provisions is expected to impact loan volumes, particularly during the initial adjustment period. Industry analyses suggest that such regulatory changes can lead to a significant reduction in loan origination.

For instance, the CFPB's internal analysis indicated that the 2017 rule's mandatory underwriting provisions could have reduced the total number of payday loans made by half.

While the current provisions focus on payment practices rather than underwriting, the operational changes required may still lead to:

• Decreased Loan Approvals: As systems and staff adapt to new compliance requirements, there may be delays or more stringent criteria applied, reducing the number of approved loans.

• Consumer Hesitancy: Borrowers may be deterred by new procedures or increased scrutiny, leading to a temporary decline in loan applications.

It's prudent to prepare for a potential downturn in loan volumes during the initial months post-implementation, with gradual recovery as processes stabilize and both staff and consumers acclimate to the new requirements.

Recommendations:

• Engage with Technology Providers: Initiate discussions with LMS vendors to assess their compliance capabilities and how they can integrate with your current operations.

• Conduct Impact Assessments: Perform thorough analyses to project the financial implications of compliance, including potential revenue losses and the costs of technology upgrades.

• Develop Mitigation Strategies: Explore avenues such as product diversification, process optimization, and consumer education to offset potential declines in loan volumes and maintain profitability.

By proactively addressing these areas, your lending operation can better navigate the regulatory changes and sustain its market position.

Our Opinion

The new rules will help big institutions but make things harder for smaller lenders because they will have to spend more on following the rules. The expected drop in revenue is important, as the CFPB predicts a 50% decrease in loans. Lenders need to understand this to see how it might affect them. The March 2025 deadline is coming up fast, so it's important to get ready and be well-prepared!

1-Minute Video: Simplify Business Verification: One Secretary of State API for All States

Headlines You Don’t Want to Miss

MN AG Ellison Targets High-Interest Predatory Lenders

Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison is intensifying efforts to combat predatory lending practices by supporting legislation that caps annual interest rates at 36%. Simultaneously, his office is taking legal action against firms like Enova International for offering loans with rates exceeding 175%.

Google Ad Ban Targets High-APR Payday Lenders

In July 13, 2025 Google will prohibit ads from payday lenders charging over 36% APR, extending its consumer protection ethos by rejecting promotions for high-interest loans and similar services. Critics voice concerns over restricted credit access for low-income earners due to these bans.

SALT Launches App for Crypto-Backed Loans Management

SALT's new mobile app makes managing loans simple. Users can apply for, repay, and track loans and credit right from their phones. Soon, the app will also let users track prices and get real-time alerts, making it even more convenient.