- Beyond Banks
- Posts
- Madison Realty Capital $585M Foreclosure Battle
Madison Realty Capital $585M Foreclosure Battle
RICO Allegations Expose Construction Lending Liability Risks

Madison Realty Capital has initiated foreclosure proceedings on a $585 million construction loan to Five Star Development for The Ritz-Carlton Paradise Valley project, with a trustee sale scheduled for November 12, 2025. The foreclosure follows Five Star's alleged default on construction deadlines and loan maturity in early June 2025.
Deal Structure and Default
The May 2023 loan financed completion of the $2 billion mixed-use development, featuring a 215-room Ritz-Carlton resort and 80 luxury villas. The loan was cross-collateralized with Five Star's El Paso property portfolio, arranged by JLL Capital Markets when the project was reported 80% complete.
RICO Counterattack
Five Star Development has filed suit under Arizona's RICO statutes, alleging Madison Realty Capital engaged in racketeering by forging founder Gerald Ayoub's signature to approve unauthorized costs, withholding construction payments while directing unbudgeted work, improperly crediting loan payments to manufacture defaults, and deliberately interfering with construction to extract concessions.
Madison denied all allegations and filed a motion to dismiss in June, characterizing the claims as a "last-ditch effort to avoid fulfilling obligations." Five Star secured a temporary injunction blocking foreclosure on the El Paso collateral properties, with their attorney claiming they "won round one."
Current Status
Legal deadlines approach rapidly: an August 29 filing deadline in the ongoing lawsuit and November 11 for parties to present foreclosure objections. The Town of Paradise Valley has halted permits for completed villas due to missed resort construction timelines, stalling approximately $150 million in villa sales and exacerbating Five Star's financial distress.
Sources:
- $2B Paradise Valley project faces foreclosure threat — Phoenix Business
- Journal Lender moves to foreclose on $2B Ritz-Carlton Paradise Valley — Orion Prop
- Paradise Valley luxury project faces foreclosure threat — Rose Law Group Reporter
- Five Star Scores Legal Win Against Madison Realty Capital — The Real Deal Texas
- Ritz-Carlton Paradise Valley Fight Could End in Foreclosure — AZBEX
- Five Star Fends off Madison Realty's Ritz Carlton Foreclosure — The Real Deal Texas
Critical Lessons for Alternative Lenders: When Construction Deals Become Courtroom Battles
This foreclosure battle exposes fundamental risks in construction lending that every alternative lender must understand. The Madison-Five Star dispute illustrates how quickly protective oversight can become litigation liability, and why even seasoned lenders with sophisticated structures can find themselves in extended legal warfare.
Construction Lending Oversight: The Dangerous Middle Ground
The RICO allegations center on Madison's level of involvement in construction management, highlighting the precarious balance lenders must maintain between protecting their investment and avoiding interference claims.
Experienced construction lenders know that inadequate oversight leads to cost overruns and delays, while excessive involvement creates liability exposure. Madison's alleged actions, directing unbudgeted work while withholding payments, exemplify the dangerous middle ground that creates maximum legal exposure.
Alternative lenders should establish clear boundaries in loan documentation regarding construction oversight responsibilities. Loan agreements must specify exactly which decisions require lender approval versus borrower discretion. Documentation should include detailed procedures for cost overrun approvals, change order processes, and payment authorization protocols. These provisions protect lenders from both interference claims and unauthorized cost escalation while maintaining necessary project control.
Cross-Collateralization Strategy: Geographic Risk Concentration
Madison's cross-collateralization with El Paso properties demonstrates both the power and complexity of multi-asset security structures. The strategy provided additional collateral for the $585 million exposure but created multi-jurisdictional enforcement challenges when Five Star obtained injunctive relief blocking foreclosure on the Texas properties. This geographic separation between primary collateral and backup security can complicate workout scenarios and extend resolution timelines.
Sophisticated lenders structure cross-collateralized deals to minimize jurisdictional complications through careful entity structuring and guarantee frameworks. Primary and secondary collateral should ideally operate under unified legal frameworks to prevent borrowers from forum shopping or obtaining piecemeal injunctive relief.
Alternative lenders should also consider the operational complexity of managing geographically dispersed assets during potential workout scenarios, including local counsel requirements and varying state foreclosure procedures.
The allegation that Madison forged Gerald Ayoub's signature reveals critical vulnerabilities in loan administration procedures. Forgery claims, even if ultimately unsuccessful, create significant litigation exposure and reputational risk for lenders. These allegations often arise from poor documentation practices, unclear authorization procedures, or inadequate verification protocols during loan administration.
Alternative lenders must implement robust signature verification and authorization procedures, particularly for construction draws and cost overrun approvals. Electronic signature platforms with audit trails provide stronger documentation than traditional wet signatures. Lenders should require multiple authorization levels for significant decisions and maintain detailed records of all borrower communications and approvals.
Clear procedures for emergency decisions when borrower principals are unavailable can prevent situations where lenders feel compelled to act without proper authorization.
RICO Weaponization: Criminal Statutes in Civil Disputes
Five Star's use of RICO allegations represents an escalating trend of borrowers weaponizing criminal statutes in civil lending disputes. RICO claims, even when ultimately unsuccessful, create significant legal costs, reputational damage, and settlement pressure for lenders. The broad language of racketeering statutes allows creative attorneys to characterize routine lending activities as patterns of criminal conduct.
Lenders should anticipate RICO exposure in contentious workout situations and structure their activities accordingly. Clear documentation of business justifications for all lender actions helps defend against pattern-of-conduct allegations. Legal counsel should review workout strategies for potential RICO exposure, particularly when lenders take active roles in borrower operations or asset management. Alternative lenders should also consider RICO insurance coverage as part of their professional liability programs, as traditional E&O policies may not cover criminal allegations.
Market Timing and Project Viability Assessment
The Paradise Valley project's ultra-luxury positioning in a limited market exemplifies the importance of rigorous market analysis in construction lending. A 215-room resort plus 80 luxury villas in Paradise Valley's small, wealthy enclave represents significant market concentration risk that likely contributed to the project's financial distress. Lenders must assess not just construction completion risk but fundamental market absorption capacity.
Alternative lenders should conduct independent market studies for large projects, particularly in niche luxury segments with limited buyer pools. Analysis should include absorption timelines, competitive supply, and economic sensitivity testing for target demographics. Construction loans for luxury projects require careful stress testing of sales velocity assumptions and contingency planning for extended marketing periods. Lenders should also consider phased funding structures that tie disbursements to pre-sales milestones rather than construction completion percentages.
Workout Complexity in Multi-Asset Structures
The multi-jurisdictional nature of Madison's collateral package demonstrates how sophisticated security structures can complicate enforcement actions. While cross-collateralization provides additional security, it can also create procedural obstacles that extend workout timelines and increase legal costs. Borrowers can exploit jurisdictional differences to obtain temporary relief and negotiate from stronger positions.
Alternative lenders should anticipate workout scenarios when structuring multi-asset deals and plan enforcement strategies accordingly. Intercreditor agreements should address coordination requirements between different jurisdictions and asset classes. Lenders should also consider the operational challenges of simultaneously managing construction assets and stabilized income properties during enforcement proceedings. Clear workout protocols and pre-negotiated asset management arrangements can streamline the process when disputes arise.
Our Opinion
This case establishes concerning precedents for alternative lenders regarding borrower litigation tactics and lender liability exposure. If Five Star's RICO claims gain traction, other distressed borrowers may adopt similar strategies to delay foreclosures and extract settlements. The case also highlights how construction lending oversight, a necessary component of prudent risk management, can be recharacterized as interference when deals go sideways.
Alternative lenders should view this case as a wake-up call regarding litigation risk in construction lending. Enhanced documentation, clear procedural boundaries, and proactive legal counsel involvement can help mitigate exposure. However, the fundamental tension between protective oversight and interference liability remains an ongoing challenge that requires careful navigation on every construction deal.
1-Minute Video: Secretary of State Websites Nightmare: How Smart Lenders Standardize It All
Lenders know the inefficiencies caused by fragmented, inconsistent public business data.
With Cobalt Intelligence, we take care of the hard work for you by gathering, cleaning, and organizing Secretary of State data from all 50 states.
You can now streamline processes, save time, and redirect efforts to strategic work.
Subscribe to our Beyond Banks Podcast Channels
Headlines You Don’t Want to Miss
Ares Management has topped the direct lender rankings as direct lending activity reached unprecedented highs in 2025. In the second quarter of this year, European direct lending volumes surged to €36.7bn across 305 deals—an 89% increase in value and a 17% rise in deal count compared to the first quarter. This spike was driven by several large-ticket transactions, including the €6.5bn refinancing of Adevinta’s unitranche loan and Constellation Automotive’s £1.8bn debt refinancing.
According to Moody's, a growing number of US companies are adding new debt without seeking lender consent by negotiating more flexible covenants in their credit agreements. This trend raises concerns about increased risks for lenders and could potentially weaken investor protections in the syndicated loan market.
Commercial real estate investment and lending activity rebounded in Q2 2025, with total investment rising 13% year-over-year to $96.9billion and lending volumes up 66%, led by private and alternative lenders. Financing conditions improved as banks increased origination and underwriting eased, driving renewed investor interest across office, retail, and industrial sectors.
Schedule a FREE Demo Call with Jordan
Get Free Access to our Alternative Finance Disclosure Law Helper GPT
Get Free Access to our Cobalt Modern Underwriter GPT
Get Free Access to our Alternative Funding Expert GPT
Get Free Access to our AI Credit Risk Tool
Create an account to Get Free Access to our Secretary of State AI Tool
![]() | Subscribe on our YouTube Channel here |
See us on LinkedIn |